What the Federal IDR Data Shows Providers

Providers won most line items decided in the CMS Federal IDR data for Q4 2025. See awards against the QPA, default losses and what it means for your practice.

Consult an Expert

30 minutes with a billing specialist.

Illustration: federal IDR line items are read, win rates and awards against the QPA are compared, and default losses are flagged.

Providers won 82.3% of line items decided in the CMS Federal IDR public data for the 2025 Q4 release, which covers 1,407,684 line items in 532,542 disputes. The typical filer’s median award was 4.9x the qualifying payment amount (QPA), and 12.9% of provider losses came from default decisions rather than from an arbitrator weighing the offers.

Five headline findings

82.3%

of line items went to the provider’s offer (84.2% once default decisions are set aside), across 1,407,684 line items in 532,542 disputes.

4.9x

the QPA was the typical filer’s median award. For neuromonitoring filers the median was 32.2x; for emergency medicine, 3.9x; for radiology, 2.6x.

12.9%

of provider losses were default decisions: 32,014 line items, or 2.3% of all line items. In radiology the share was 26%.

60%

of line items were filed from the 10 most common filing email domains. The top 25 domains account for 83%.

92%

of the payer line items we could count involved four payer families: Blue Cross Blue Shield plans, UnitedHealthcare, Aetna and Cigna. Texas alone accounts for 44% of disputes.

Specialty-level award multiples are medians across filer records with 30 or more line items. Surgical assist rests on only 19 filer records, so read it as indicative.

What this means for independent practices

The IDR process is where an out-of-network underpayment gets decided by a third party, and this release shows that providers who reach a decision win most of the time. About one in eight provider losses came from a missed deadline or an unpaid fee, so procedure deserves as much attention as the offer itself.

Know Your QPA by Payer

Know your QPA for your top five codes by payer before you file. The award multiple ranges from about 2.6x of QPA for radiology to 54.3x for neurosurgery and spine at the typical filer.

Track the Two Failure Points

Track the deadline to submit your offer and the fee payment. These are the two procedural failure points in the data.

Compare Your Payer Mix

If one payer family is most of your out-of-network volume, its behavior is most of your results. Compare your mix with the national picture.

Ask Who Files for You

Ask whoever files for you how many of your line items were decided and how many were lost by default, using the same definitions as this study.

Get the full IDR outcomes study

The full study breaks results out by specialty and payer, with code-level tables for anesthesia, neuromonitoring, surgical assist, neurosurgery and spine, orthopedics, radiology and emergency medicine. Enter your practice email and the 19-page PDF opens right away. We will also send short updates when IDR rules or results change.

Methods and source

Source: CMS Federal IDR public use files, 2025 Q4, as published at cms.gov/nosurprises. We worked from extracts holding 13,626 filer records (one per provider group name and NPI) and 1,407,684 line items. Initiation dates in the file run from 2022-04-21 to 2025-12-18, so a case’s start date can be well before the release quarter.

Win rates and default shares are computed on line items, and a dispute can contain many line items. We never average medians. Specialty comes from a free-text field filled in by the filer, mapped with keyword rules, so some mapping error is unavoidable. Results are one quarter’s release, and outcomes are not payments. This page is general information and not legal advice.

Related tools, guides and services

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the Federal IDR process?

It is the arbitration route under the No Surprises Act for out-of-network payment disputes. A third party decides between the provider's offer and the payer's offer, and weighs the qualifying payment amount (QPA) alongside other information in the dispute.

Where does this data come from?

The CMS Federal IDR public use files for 2025 Q4, published at cms.gov/nosurprises. The study works from extracts of those files and reports counts, win rates and medians.

Does a win in IDR mean the practice was paid?

No. An award is a decision about which offer wins. It is not money received, and it does not cover time to collection, the administrative fees both parties pay, or a plan that does not pay an award.

Can I look up a specific code?

Yes. The IDR award lookup shows the median QPA, offers, award and provider win rate for codes with at least 100 line items in the same release.

Have a claim that might qualify for IDR?

Book a free 30-minute call. We will look at whether the claim qualifies and how open negotiation and the IDR process would run. Read more about No Surprises Act IDR support.

Consult an Expert

© 2026 Happy Billing LLC. All Rights Reserved. · Privacy Policy · Terms