HaloMD Alternatives: NSA IDR Companies Compared (2026)

Last reviewed: November 2026. Facts about other companies are taken from their own public pages, linked below.
Disclosure: Happy Billing wrote this page and is one of the four options listed. We describe the other companies using only what they say on their own websites, we link every source, and we write “not stated” where a page is silent. We do not rank the options. We also do not repeat any company’s win rates, recovery totals or other results, because they are self-reported and cannot be checked from the outside.
The short answer
If you own an out-of-network practice and are choosing who will handle your federal No Surprises Act (NSA) disputes, the companies in this comparison fall into four types. HaloMD says it focuses exclusively on independent dispute resolution (IDR). Callagy Recovery says it grew out of a law firm and also covers state arbitration, hospital claims and underpayment appeals. Aspirion describes a broad revenue recovery business that includes out-of-network recovery. Happy Billing is a billing and revenue cycle company that handles open negotiation and federal IDR in-house.
What matters for you is not the label. It is who files, who follows up after an award, how you pay, and whether the same team also works the claims that never qualify for IDR.
What you are actually buying
Federal IDR is the process an out-of-network provider can use when open negotiation with a payer fails on a claim the No Surprises Act covers. Whoever runs it for you decides whether a claim is eligible, sends the open negotiation notice, files inside the deadlines, assembles the case and tracks the result. Most owners are not choosing arbitration itself. They are choosing who does the work and how the money flows.
Three questions separate the options:
- Does this company only do IDR, or also everything around it? Claims that do not qualify for the federal process, including many office-based out-of-network claims, still need someone to work them.
- How do fees work, and who pays filing costs up front? The answer affects your cash position and your risk on a lost dispute.
- What happens after an award? Getting paid is a separate step from winning, and companies describe it differently.
Comparison table: what each company says publicly (as of November 2026)
| HaloMD | Callagy Recovery | Aspirion | Happy Billing | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| What it describes itself as | “An exclusive focus on Independent Dispute Resolution” [1] | Provider-side recovery covering federal IDR, state arbitration, hospital claims and underpayments; says it grew out of Callagy Law [2] | Revenue integrity services: A/R management, denials management, out-of-network recovery, payment variance recovery [3] | Medical billing and revenue cycle company that also does out-of-network recovery and No Surprises Act work |
| Federal No Surprises Act IDR | Yes; says submissions follow “federal or state-specific IDR guidelines” [1] | Yes; describes IDR submissions “across 13 federal venues” [2] | Its out-of-network page covers NSA deadlines and the open negotiation window; IDR itself is not explained on the page [4] | Yes. See No Surprises Act IDR recovery |
| State law arbitration | References state balance-billing laws; specific states not stated [1] | Yes; lists state-level arbitration and says it represents providers from “all 50 states” [2] | Not stated [3][4] | Ask on the call which process applies to each claim |
| Routine billing and denials | Not stated; every listed step is part of the IDR workflow [1] | Not stated as routine billing; lists hospital claim recovery and underpayment appeals [2] | Denials management and A/R management listed [3] | Yes, full-service billing and denial management |
| Credentialing | Not stated [1] | Not stated [2] | Not stated [3] | Yes. See credentialing |
| Other claim types listed | Not stated [1] | Emergency care, hospital claim recovery, medical claim underpayment recovery [2] | Motor vehicle accident, workers’ compensation, VA-TRICARE, out-of-state Medicaid [3] | Out-of-network underpayment recovery on repriced claims. See out-of-network underpayment recovery |
| Fee terms on its site | Not stated; the call to action is “Request a Demo” [1] | Publishes contingency terms, an exit window and that it advances filing fees; see its site for current terms [2] | Not stated; says “We only succeed when you do” [3] | Out-of-network recovery is on contingency; terms quoted on a call |
| Who it says it serves | “Healthcare providers,” including specialties “most affected by out-of-network disputes” [1] | “Medical providers”; the emergency care page is titled “for Surgeons and Hospitals” [2] | Health systems and providers [3] | Independently owned practices with 1 to 50 providers |
| EHR connectivity | Not stated [1] | Says “Direct API connectivity to Epic and Cerner” [2]; its app page says Epic connectivity is enabled separately by each Epic customer and that file upload is an alternative [5] | Not stated [3] | Works inside your existing EHR |
Sources, all read in November 2026:
[1] HaloMD: halomd.com
[2] Callagy Recovery: callagyrecovery.com
[3] Aspirion: aspirion.com
[4] Aspirion, Out-of-Network Recovery: aspirion.com/out-of-network-recovery
[5] Callagy Recovery, Arbitration on Demand app: callagyrecovery.com/arbitration-on-demand-app
“Not stated” means the page we read does not say. It does not mean the company lacks the capability. Companies update their pages, so confirm current terms with the company before you decide.
Who each option fits
HaloMD
HaloMD’s own description is a company dedicated to IDR, with a platform that runs from documentation through negotiation to reporting [1]. That focus can suit a provider group whose main need is IDR filing and that already has billing and denials handled elsewhere. Its public page does not state fees, so ask for current terms in writing and ask what happens to claims that fall outside IDR.
Callagy Recovery
Callagy Recovery publishes the most specific commercial terms of the four, and says Callagy Law has the ability to enforce awards [2]. Its service pages name surgeons and hospitals, and its stated reach includes federal IDR, state arbitration and hospital claim recovery. That profile can suit surgeons, facility-based groups and organizations with Epic or Cerner environments. If you consider it, ask what the percentage applies to (the award, the increase over the payer’s offer, or collections) and what the 30-day exit requires, since the homepage does not define either.
Aspirion
Aspirion describes a wide recovery business across denials, A/R, out-of-network recovery and complex claim types such as motor vehicle accident and workers’ compensation [3]. It names health systems as its core audience. That can suit an organization that wants one recovery partner across many claim categories. Its pages do not describe IDR itself or its fee terms, so ask both questions directly, and confirm fit for a practice of your size.
Happy Billing
We fit independently owned practices that want open negotiation and federal IDR handled by the same team that bills for them. Claims that qualify for the federal process are filed and tracked. Claims that do not qualify, such as office-based claims repriced by Data iSight, MultiPlan or Zelis, go through our out-of-network underpayment recovery work. Credentialing, payer contract renegotiation, denial management and old A/R sit with the same company, so you are not coordinating several vendors. We handle the daily work and recovery. We fit less well if you only want a standalone arbitration service and already have a billing team you are happy with, or if you run a hospital or large health system.
Questions to ask any IDR vendor
- How do you decide a claim is eligible, and who is accountable if a filing is rejected as ineligible?
- Who pays the federal fees and the arbitrator’s fee up front, and who bears them if a dispute is lost?
- What does your fee apply to? The award, the increase over the payer’s offer, or collections each produce a different bill.
- What happens after an award if the payer does not pay?
- Do you handle the claims that fall outside federal IDR, or do I need another vendor for those?
- Who talks to the payer on my claims, and will I be told before anything is filed?
- What reporting will I get on each case, and how often?
How Happy Billing approaches IDR
You hand over one set of claims. We sort them by the process that fits: open negotiation first, federal IDR when a claim is eligible and negotiation has not resolved it, and our underpayment recovery work for claims the No Surprises Act does not cover. Nobody on your side has to track which dispute belongs to which vendor, and everyday billing, credentialing and payer contract renegotiation stay with the same team.
Talk to us about your IDR claims
Bring a sample of your out-of-network claims and the payers involved. We will tell you which are likely eligible for the federal process, which are not, and what we would do with each. Our office is at 5333 Westheimer Rd, Houston, TX, and the phone is +1-832-384-4250.
Frequently asked questions
What is a No Surprises Act IDR company?
It is a company that prepares and files federal independent dispute resolution cases for a provider. That includes checking eligibility, meeting deadlines, building the case and tracking the outcome. It is different from the certified IDR entities, which act as the neutral decision-makers in the dispute.
Do I need an IDR specialist or a billing company that also does IDR?
It depends on how much of your out-of-network revenue is eligible for IDR. If most of it is, a specialist can be efficient. If you also have office-based or repriced claims that fall outside federal IDR, a team that covers both avoids gaps and handoffs.
How do IDR companies charge?
Models vary. Callagy Recovery publishes a contingent fee structure with filing fees advanced by the company. HaloMD and Aspirion do not state fee terms on the pages we read. Ask any company for terms in writing, including who pays fees up front and what the percentage applies to.
Can I switch IDR vendors while cases are open?
Often, but it depends on the stage of each dispute and on your contract. Ask the new company how it handles in-flight cases, and ask your current company what its agreement says about open files and exit.
Does IDR cover all of my out-of-network claims?
No. Federal IDR applies to claims covered by the No Surprises Act. Other out-of-network claims follow different rules, and some states have their own arbitration. A good vendor tells you in advance which of your claims fit which path.
How does Happy Billing charge for IDR work?
Our out-of-network underpayment recovery is on contingency. For No Surprises Act work, we quote the specifics on a call, based on your claims, and put them in writing before you sign.